registration mark

Earth Insitute Columbia University



logo

São Tomé e Príncipe 2004 National Forum

Sao Tome and Principe's 2004 National Forum was both a unique experiment in participatory democracy and a chance to educate Santomeans on the issue of their country's anticipated oil revenues.  The success of the Forum illustrates the determination of Santomeans to move beyond the closed-door politics too often associated with oil economies.

A commitment to hold a National Forum was included in the Memorandum of Understanding that ended STP's political crisis of July 2003.  Events called "National Forums" had been held in 1997 and 1998, but these events were not successful.  In March 2004, President Fradique de Menezes visited Columbia University for discussions of the new legislation, governance institutions and public investments needed in his country.  At that time, Columbia faculty suggested a design for more decentralized kind of forum, aimed at simultaneously informing and consulting the public at large.  The idea was well received and led to the announcement by President de Menezes of a new forum process in STP on April 27th

Columbia University researchers traveled to Sao Tome and Principe to assist with the Forum, which took place between June 16th and July 12th, 2004.  In a series of 56 public meetings around the country, citizens were presented with a popular information bulletin (English) (Portuguese version) explaining the oil situation, and a questionnaire (English, Portuguese) eliciting their preferences for public investment.  The questionnaire results were presented at a series of national-level meetings, providing a foundation upon which citizen delegates and political leaders could base their arguments. 

In spite of many political and logistical obstacles, the Forum ended on Independence Day with hundreds of Santomeans holding hands, delivering to lawmakers the results of an unprecedented exercise in civic participation. 

Key Documents on the 2004 Forum

Forum Video (in Portuguese) footage taken by RTP Africa (courtesy of Valdimir Antonio)

  • 06/15/04 National Forum Introduction and Facilitator Training
    This segment introduces the National Forum at its planning stage and includes an interview with Reverend Jose Dias Marques. The Columbia Team appears in training sessions with Forum facilitators and moderators. (Length: 2:38) Watch Real video

  • 06/16/04 Opening of the National Forum:
    This segment provides footage and highlights from the Opening Ceremony of the National Forum. Parts of Reverend Marques and President de Menezes's Opening Ceremony speeches are broadcast. Dates and National Forum details are provided. (Length: 1:40) Watch Real video

  • 06/18/04 Day Two of the National Forum, Santa Catarina Meeting
    Content: This segment provides details about the how the National Forum meetings are progressing, including interviews with several participants in Santa Catarina. This segment is somewhat critical and emphasizes people's skepticism of the National Forum. Forum facilitator Olavio Anibal is also interviewed. (Length: 2:50) Watch Real video
  • 07/5/04 National Forum Centralized Meetings, Day One
    This segment introduces stage two of the National Forum, the centralized meeting with community delegates in the capital. The central objectives of the centralized meeting are explained. Interviews with Reverend Marques and delegates are provided. (Length: 2:04) Watch Real video
  • 07/6/04 National Forum Centralized Meetings, Day Two
    This segment reviews the objectives of the National Forum centralized meetings and looks at its progress. The dispute over whether delegates will get paid is also briefly mentioned. Executive Committee member Maria do Carmo Silveira is interviewed.(Length: 1:44) Watch Real video
  • 07/7/04 Payment Dispute Involving National Forum Delegates
    This segment highlights the growing dispute between the National Forum and the Forum's community delegates over whether they should be paid to attend the centralized Forum meetings. Interviews with the leaders of the protest are provided. (Length: 2:12) Watch Real video
  • 07/8/04 Payment Dispute Involving National Forum Delegates, Part II
    This segment provides an update on negotiations between the Forum delegates, the Forum's Executive Committee and the national government regarding payment of the delegates. Interviews with President de Menezes and Reverend Marques are provided. (Length: 2:00) Watch Real video
  • 07/11/04 Closing of National Forum, Day One
    This segment provides footage from the first day of the National Forum's Plenary (Closing) Sessions. The segment refers to the National Forum thus far as a "success." The segment mentions that politico-institutional, social and development issues and topics were discussed. Interviews with President de Menezes, Prime Minister Maria das Neves and Forum delegates are also provided. (Length: 3:70) Watch Real video
  • 07/12/04 Closing of National Forum, Day Two
    This segment provides footage from the final day of the National Forum. The segment reflects on some of the controversial aspects of the Forum's final conclusions and recommendations. Footage of Executive Committee member Justino Veiga reading aloud some of these final 45 recommendations is provided. Footage of the crowd holding hands in unison is also shown. (Length: 1:42) Watch Real video

Historical documents regarding previous forums

Acknowledgements and credits

Columbia University's support to the National Forum in STP was provided by Clara Albuquerque, Joshua Chaffin, Paulo Cunha and Christine Weydig, under a grant from the United Nations Development Programme.   Activities were managed by the Columbia University country coordinator, Jan Hartman, and led by William Masters with Macartan Humphreys and Martin Sandbu, under the general Sao Tome and Principe Advisory Project funded by the Open Society Institute.


 


 

São Tomé e Príncipe

Forum Nacional - 2004

Realização do Forum

Resultados do Questionário

Fotos do Forum

O Forum Nacional - 2004 em São Tomé e Príncipe foi tanto uma experiência única em democracia participativa como também uma oportunidade de instruir os santomenses sobre a questão dos recursos petrolíferos do país. O sucesso do Forum ilustra a determinação dos santomenses em ultrapassar a "política de portas fechadas" comumente associada com as economias do petróleo.

O compromisso de realizar um Forum Nacional fez parte do Memorando de Entendimento que pôs fim à crise política de STP em julho de 2003. Eventos denominados "Foruns Nacionais" foram realizados em 1997 e 1998, mas não foram bem-sucedidos. 

Em março de 2004, o Presidente Fradique de Menezes visitou a Universidade de Columbia e participou em discussões sobre a nova legislação, as instituições para governação e os investimentos públicos necessários para seu país. Naquela data, os professores da Columbia sugeriram um desenho descentralizado para o forum, com o objectivo de simultaneamente informar e consultar o público em geral. A idéia foi bem recebida e no dia 27 de abril o Presidente Fradique de Menezes anunciou um novo processo para o forum em São Tomé e Príncipe.

Os pesquisadores da Universidade de Columbia viajaram a São Tomé e Príncipe para auxiliar na implementação do Forum, que ocorreu entre 16 de junho e 12 de julho de 2004. Em uma série de 56 audiências públicas por todo o país, os cidadãos receberam um boletim de informação popular (inglês) com explicações sobre a situação do petróleo, e um questionário (inglês, português) evocando suas preferências para investimentos públicos. Os resultados do questionário foram apresentados em uma série de encontros nacionais, proporcionando um alicerce sobre o qual os delegados (representantes da população) e os líderes políticos podem fundamentar seus argumentos.

Apesar de muitos obstáculos políticos e logísticos, o Forum foi concluído no Dia da Independência com centenas de santomenses dando-se as mãos, e entregando aos legisladores os resultados de um exercício de participação cívica sem precendente.

Documentos Relevantes

•  Termos de Referência para o Forum de 1997 em português

•  Lições obtidas do Forum de 1998 em francês

•  Decreto presidencial sobre a organização do Forum, em português

•  Planejamento Oficial do Forum, em português

•  Boletim de Informação Popular* ( versão em português, com cartazes*)

•  Questionário (inglês) ( português )

•  Relatório final da equipa da Columbia sobre o Forum Nacional

 

 

 


For further information on this project, in Sao Tome please contact: Jan Hartman at +239 90 65 77 or email janhartman@cstome.net. In New York, please contact Professor Jeffrey Sachs at sachs@columbia.edu, or Will Masters at wmasters@ei.columbia.edu.